Christmas Desserts

Get ready to sleigh the season with our Christmas Collection! From jolly cakes to merry cookies, these festive treats are here to make your holidays extra sweet and totally magical!

Filter
FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
Sort by
Available Seasonal Dates OnlyPre-Ordering ClosedRequires 72 Hours Notice
Iced Christmas Cookies
From $ 3.60
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Happy Holidays Custom Cookie Gift Box
From $ 27.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Retro Christmas Custom Cookie Gift Box
From $ 27.95
Available Seasonal Dates OnlyPre-Ordering ClosedRequires 72 Hours Notice
Yule Log - Bûche de Noël
From $ 96.95

2 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Merry Christmas Custom Cookie Gift Box
From $ 27.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
You're A Mean One
From $ 149.95

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Holiday TP Cake
From $ 104.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Incredibly Christmas
From $ 149.95

2 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Mr. Snowman
From $ 233.00
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Blue Scarf Snowman
From $ 277.00
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Winter Wonderland
From $ 94.95

2 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Cake Cookie Collection
$ 29.95

19 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Red Nose
From $ 149.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Red and Gold Ornament
From $ 193.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Blue and Silver Ornament
From $ 193.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Holiday Snowflake
From $ 87.95
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Pastel Cheer
From $ 250.00
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Tres Leches Dessert Cake
$ 108.95

3 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Sprinkle Butter Cookies
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Black and White Cookie
$ 5.75

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Chocolate Chip Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Russian Tea Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Raspberry Butter Cookie
From $ 10.98

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Sea Salt Caramel Cake Cookie
From $ 10.98

2 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
No Sugar Added Cake in a Jar
$ 7.55
Requires 72 Hours Notice
M&M Butter Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Cinnamon Walnut Rugelach
From $ 12.43

3 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Fudge Thumbprint Cookie
From $ 10.98

3 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Berry Shortcake in a Jar
$ 7.55
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Nonpareils Butter Cookies
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Fudge Butter Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Raspberry Chocolate Rugelach
From $ 12.43
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Raspberry Round Sandwich
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Fudge Finger Sandwich Cookie
From $ 10.98

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Crystal Butter Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Apricot Raisin Rugelach
From $ 12.43
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Almond Cake Cookie
From $ 10.98

2 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Almond Shortbread Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Caramel Pecan Cake Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Lemon Cake Cookie
From $ 10.98

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Pecan Bar
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Almond Florentine
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Almond Bar
From $ 10.98

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
White Chocolate Macadamia Candy
From $ 10.98
Sold out

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Raspberry Raisin Rugelach
From $ 12.43

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Fudge Cake Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Maple Pecan Shortbread Cookie
From $ 10.98
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Round Custom Image Cookies
From $ 30.90