All Items

Filter
Best sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters
Sort by
Requires 1 Week Notice
Cinnamon Walnut Rugelach
From $ 12.03

2 reviews
Requires 1 Week Notice
Raspberry Raisin Rugelach
From $ 12.03

1 review
Requires 1 Week Notice
Lemon Cake Cookie
From $ 10.68

1 review
Requires 1 Week Notice
Almond Cake Cookie
From $ 10.68

2 reviews
Requires 1 Week Notice
Almond Bar
From $ 10.68

1 review
Requires 1 Week Notice
Raspberry Chocolate Rugelach
From $ 12.03
Requires 1 Week Notice
Mint Chocolate Shortbread Cookie
From $ 10.68
Available Seasonal Dates OnlyRequires 1 Week Notice
Christmas Sprinkle Butter Cookies
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Almond Shortbread Cookie
From $ 10.68
Available Seasonal Dates OnlyRequires 1 Week Notice
Christmas Nonpareils Butter Cookies
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Nonpareils Butter Cookies
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Caramel Pecan Cake Cookie
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Sea Salt Caramel Cake Cookie
From $ 10.68

2 reviews
Requires 1 Week Notice
Pecan Bar
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Chocolate Chip Wafer
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Fudge Finger Sandwich Cookie
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Raspberry Round Sandwich
From $ 10.68
Requires 1 Week Notice
Almond Florentine
From $ 10.68
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Round Custom Image Cookies
From $ 30.90
Requires 1 Week Notice
Fudge Cake Cookie
From $ 10.68
Available Seasonal Dates Only
First Friday Challah
$ 9.95

10 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Raiders Cookies
From $ 30.90
Requires 1 Week Notice
Rainbow Cookie
From $ 10.68
Requires 72 Hours Notice
I Voted Cookie
From $ 33.60
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Portrait Cookies
From $ 30.90

1 review
Available Seasonal Dates Only
World Famous Cranberry Cream Cheese Loaf
$ 10.95

3 reviews
Available Seasonal Dates Only
LOGO COOKIE & Medium Christmas Tree Tray
$ 30.45
Available Seasonal Dates Only
LOGO COOKIE & Christmas Wrapped Cookie Tray
From $ 40.55
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Cherry Hearts
From $ 94.95

4 reviews
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Devoted Heart
From $ 87.95

4 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Love Bunny
From $ 115.95

4 reviews
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Pastel Rainbow Heart
From $ 96.95

4 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
My Heart Bleeds for You
From $ 135.95

4 reviews
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Floral Love
From $ 43.95
Requires 48 Hours Notice
What's Your Sign?
From $ 96.95

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Big Game Cookies
From $ 26.40
Available Seasonal Dates OnlyRequires 72 Hours Notice
Be My Cookie
From $ 13.00
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Floral Heart
From $ 96.95

4 reviews
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Icing Flower Heart
From $ 102.95

1 review
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Blush Heart
From $ 94.95

4 reviews
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Dark Heart
From $ 87.95

4 reviews
Requires 48 Hours Notice
Classic Pink Heart
From $ 87.95

4 reviews
Mother's Day Cookies
From $ 26.40
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Congratulations Cookie
From $ 26.40

1 review
Requires 72 Hours Notice
Smart Cookie
From $ 30.90

1 review
Happy 4th Cookies
From $ 26.40

1 review
Stars, Stripes, and Smiles Cookie
From $ 29.10

1 review
The Man, The Myth, The Cookie
From $ 26.40

1 review